The lowest-priced winner of the GH Beauty Lab’s anti-aging eye treatment test, Garnier’s cream effectively firmed and moisturized eye area skin. Made with shea butter and caffeine, it increased skin firmness by 32% and hydration by 31%. “It really seemed to diminish my dark circles so that I used much less concealer!” a tester raved. “It also was a great moisturizer and seemed to brighten.”